Why "Nice" Doesn't Win in Sales: Strategic Lessons from Relationship Psychology | Expert Guide 2025
|
Why "Nice" Doesn't Win in Sales: Strategic Lessons from Relationship PsychologyThere I was, watching another "nice" sales rep lose a massive deal. Sarah had done everything right – or so she thought. Perfect follow-ups, immediate responses to every client request, constant availability, and yet... the $450,000 listing went to her competitor who had barely seemed interested. As I sat with her reviewing what went wrong, it hit me: she had fallen into the same trap I'd seen countless times in my 12 years of sales leadership – the "nice trap." You know that friend who's always available, agrees with everything you say, and never challenges your thinking? How much do you really value their opinion? Or… Women Im talking to you here… What about the “nice guy” you dumped for being just “too nice”. Exactly. The same psychology applies in sales, and it's costing you deals. The Truth About Being "Nice" in SalesLet's get something straight: this isn't about being mean or aggressive. It's about being strategic and authentic. After training over 75 sales professionals and transforming multiple underperforming teams, I've discovered that "nice" is often code for "Afraid" – afraid of rejection, afraid of tension, & afraid of losing the deal. I can tell you this as a FACT. You can not lose what you never had. The Real Cost of Being Too Nice When Nikki first moved to FL she was in a new environment, with no sphere of influence, and no choice on needing to make it in Real Estate. She had one slight issue holding her back. She was the quintessential "nice" agent. Everyone loved her, but her closing rate was abysmal. Fast forward three months after implementing strategic relationship principles, and she secured 22 listings while working just 4 hours daily. The difference? She stopped trying to be nice and started being valuable. 1. Authenticity Over People-PleasingRemember the last time someone was obviously trying to sell you something? That uncomfortable feeling you got? That's your brain detecting inauthenticity. Your clients have the same detector. In one of our ISA department transformations, we discovered that reps who focused on being genuine rather than agreeable saw their conversion rates triple. They weren't rude – they were real. 2. The Power of Healthy BoundariesOne of my most successful clients doubled her close rate after implementing one simple boundary: she stopped taking unscheduled calls. Counterintuitive? Yes. Effective? Absolutely. If you’re first thought as reading this is “I don’t have the business to only take scheduled calls”... Well, go get the business to allow yourself to only take scheduled calls. Do you see how that works? If you are so booked that you are continuously in meetings during your working hours how are your clients going to talk to you? On a schedule. How do you get that booked? Follow a simple system that allows you to generate more business than you know what to do with. If you want a simple system that will allow you to create more business than you can stand, shoot me an email titled "Simple Lead Gen System" to Craig@simpru.com and I will get it over to you. Start imagining your life as productive and easy. Imagine this for a second. Client calls. You have a text that goes out(preloaded shortcut)… Hey, I am glad you called. I’m finishing up on the other line and I will call you right back. Are you going to be free in the next 15-20 mins? The thing is, why are you stopping every time someone calls you? (That's nice) Either set a time to call them back if you are busy or have someone else call them in the meantime. I am not saying don’t serve the customer. I am telling you to serve your clients better. Give them more by controlling your schedule better. Here’s what happens if you don’t.
Setting Professional Boundaries That WorkThis is all about framing. Once you get a client just let them know that you want to give them the best buying or selling experience they have ever had. In order for you to do that you will give them easy ways to get a hold of you or someone on your support team. You don’t have a support team? Yes, you do. You can find someone to help for virtually nothing. The point is here to set the standards to give a better overall experience and stick to it.
3. Challenge and Value CreationWhen we scaled our ISA department from 2 to 20+ deals monthly, the game-changer wasn't better scripts or more follow-up. It was teaching our team to challenge client assumptions constructively. A recent example: A client insisted on pricing their property 20% above market value. Instead of agreeing, we presented data showing how overpriced homes typically sell for less than market value. Result? Listed at market price, sold in 5 days. 4. Self-Respect and ConfidenceThe data doesn't lie: In analyzing over 500 closed deals, we found that sales professionals who maintained healthy boundaries closed 40% more business than their "always available" counterparts. 5. Strategic UnpredictabilityThink about the last time you were really engaged in a conversation. Was it with someone who agreed with everything you said? Or someone who made you think differently? Creating Engaging Client Relationships
6. The Problem with Being "Needed"The goal isn't to make clients need you – it's to make them value you. One of our new agents secured 5 contracts in 5 weeks not by being the most responsive, but by being the most valuable. 7. Commitment and TimingTiming is everything in sales, just like in relationships. We've found that deals closed 35% faster when reps focused on value creation rather than constant availability. 8. Building Real ValueValue isn't about being nice – it's about getting results. Period. Practical Value-Building Strategies
Action Steps for Implementation
Remember: Being strategic isn't about being difficult – it's about being valuable. Stop trying to be nice, and start focusing on being effective. |